Paradise Cafe Menu (2025 Update)

  1. Home
  2. Menu

Welcome to Paradise Cafe, a cozy culinary treasure nestled in Key West, Florida. Our menu is a vibrant celebration of Mexican-inspired flavors, offering an array of mouthwatering dishes that are crafted with love and authenticity.

  • Breakfast Delights: Enjoy our Baleada Sencilla or the hearty Desayuno Indio, featuring scrambled eggs and fresh ingredients.
  • Taco Temptations: Indulge in our flavorful Tacos al Pastor and spicy Diablo Tacos, all served with rich, homemade corn tortillas.
  • CafĂ© Comfort: Pair your meal with our delightful coffee options, including a creamy Con Leche or a refreshing iced coffee.

Patrons rave about the exceptional flavors and welcoming atmosphere, making Paradise Cafe a must-visit for locals and tourists alike. With personalized service and a dedication to quality, it's truly a haven for food lovers.

Drinks Salads Specials Lunch Sandwiches Sides Coffee Omelets Mexican Food Breakfast Platter Breakfast Sandwich

Drinks

Orange Juice 12 Oz
US$6.00

Fruit Smoothies

Choose or mix between banana, strawberry, mango and peach.
US$5.00

Mexican Coke

The same great taste made with only pure cane sugar and served in a bottle.
US$3.50

Can Coke

Coca, Sprite, ginger ale and Jupina.
US$1.75

Fresh Lemonade 16 Oz
US$5.00

Fresh Lemonade 32 Oz
US$8.00

Gatorade

A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine
US$3.50

Natural Orange Juice 16 Oz
US$7.00

Water
US$1.50

Plastic Soda

Fanta, Coca-Cola or Sprite.
US$3.50

Chicken Caesar
US$10.00

Fish Caesar
US$15.00

Shrimp Caesar
US$15.00

Salads

Specials

Fajitas Shrimp
US$22.00

Churrasco Guatemalteco

palomilla, Mexican sausage, guacamole, green onion, beans, rice, jalapeno and cheese
US$23.00

Breaded Chicken Breast

Served with black beans, rice, salad and corn tortilla.
US$20.00

Grilled Shrimp

Served with black beans, rice, salad and corn tortilla.
US$20.00

Fajitas Chicken
US$20.00

Churrasco

Served with black beans, rice, salad and corn tortilla.
US$20.00

Fajitas Steak
US$20.00

Grilled Chicken Breast

Served with black beans, rice, salad and corn tortilla.
US$18.00

Palomilla Steak

Served with black beans, rice, salad and corn tortilla.
US$20.00

Shredded Pork

Served with black beans, rice, salad and corn tortilla.
US$20.00

Grilled Fish Fillet

Served with black beans, rice, salad and corn tortilla.
US$19.00

Smoked Pork Chop

Served with black beans, rice, salad and corn tortilla.
US$20.00

Breaded Fish Fillet

Served with black beans, rice, salad and corn tortilla.
US$21.00

BLT
US$6.00

Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

Fried chicken with lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise and fries
US$13.00

Paradise Cheeseburger

bacon, lettuce, tomato, pickles, grilled onions, mushrooms, mayonnaise, ketchup, mustard and fries
US$13.00

Bacon & Cheese
US$6.00

Chicken Breast Sand

Grilled onions, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise and fries.
US$12.00

Cuban Mix

Ham, salami, Swiss cheese, grilled onions, lettuce, tomato, pickles, mustard, mayonnaise and fries.
US$13.00

Cheese Steak

Grilled onions, tomato, lettuce, mayonnaise and fries
US$12.00

Crazy Cheeseburger

double pad, bacon, avocado, lettuce, tomato, pickles, grilled onions, mushrooms, mayonnaise, ketchup, mustard and fries
US$16.00

Fresh Fish Sandwich

Grilled onions, tomato, lettuce, mayonnaise and fries
US$13.50

Croqueta Sand

Lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise
US$8.00

Ham & Cheese
US$6.00

Avocado Chicken Sandwich

Grilled onions, lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise and fries.
US$14.00

Lunch Sandwiches

Sides

Guacamole & Chips
US$8.00

Ham
US$3.12

Single Egg
US$1.56

Corn Beef Side
US$5.20

Chicken
US$3.12

Fries
US$4.00

Avocado
US$3.12

Empanadas

choose between chicken or beef
US$3.50

Steak
US$3.12

Hot Sauce
US$0.50

Chorizo
US$3.12

Chicken Tenders
US$10.00

Buffalo Wings
US$10.00

Jalapeno Tereado
US$1.00

Hashbrown
US$1.75

Rice & Beans
US$5.00

Fish & Chips
US$11.25

Croquetas
US$1.00

Side Of Bacon
US$4.00

Garcia Sausage
US$3.00

Single Taco
US$4.00

Sweet Plantains
US$5.00

Medium Con Leche
US$3.25

Cappuccino
US$5.00

Small Con Leche
US$2.25

Hot Chocolate Milk
US$5.00

Iced Coffee 16 Oz
US$5.00

Half Colada

Two shots of espresso.
US$2.00

Colada

Four shots of espresso.
US$3.00

Iced Coffee 12 Oz
US$4.00

Large Con Leche
US$4.00

Buchi
US$1.00

Cortadito
US$3.50

Coffee

Omelets

Shrimp Omelet
US$15.00

Western Omelet
US$14.00

Vegetable Omelet
US$13.00

Meat Lovers
US$15.00

Ham & Cheese Omelet
US$13.00

Pork Burrito

Rice, black beans, cheese, pico de gallo wrapped on a flour tortilla. Side of fries, sour cream and hot sauce on the side.
US$14.50

Pork Quesadilla

Grilled onions and peppers. Side of fries, sour cream and hot sauce on the side.
US$15.00

Chicken Tacos

Three tacos with onion, cilantro and avocado on the top.
US$12.50

Chorizo Nachos
US$15.00

Steak Tacos

Three tacos with onion, cilantro and avocado on the top.
US$12.50

Chicken Nachos
US$15.00

Chorizo Tacos

Three tacos with onion, cilantro and avocado on the top.
US$12.50

Shrimp Burrito

Rice, black beans, cheese, pico de gallo wrapped on a flour tortilla. Side of fries, sour cream and hot sauce on the side.
US$16.00

Diabla Tacos

Three tacos with onion, cilantro and avocado on the top.
US$14.50

Shrimp Quesadilla

Grilled onions and peppers. Side of fries, sour cream and hot sauce on the side.
US$16.00

Steak Nachos
US$15.00

Pastor Tacos

Three tacos with onion, cilantro and avocado on the top.
US$14.50

Steak Quesadilla

Grilled onions and peppers. Side of fries, sour cream and hot sauce on the side.
US$15.00

Carnita Tacos

Three tacos with onion, cilantro and avocado on the top.
US$12.50

Gordo Quesadilla

Chorizo and steak. Grilled onions and peppers. Side of fries, sour cream and hot sauce on the side.
US$16.00

Fish Tacos

Three tacos with onion, cilantro and avocado on the top.
US$15.00

Shrimp Tacos
US$13.50

Shrimp Nachos
US$16.00

Steak Burrito

Rice, black beans, cheese, pico de gallo wrapped on a flour tortilla. Side of fries, sour cream and hot sauce on the side.
US$14.50

Chicken Burrito
US$14.00

Pastor Quesadilla

Grilled onions and peppers. Side of fries, sour cream and hot sauce on the side.
US$15.50

Chicken Quesadilla

Grilled onions and peppers. Side of fries, sour cream and hot sauce on the side.
US$14.50

Mexican Food

Breakfast Platter

Tostadas Chapinas

Four fried tortillas with beans, steak, chorizo, avocado, pico de Gallo and cheese
US$17.00

Desayuno Catracho

Eggs with chorizo, sweet plantains, avocado, black beans, cheese and home made flour tortilla
US$16.00

Desayuno Chapin

Two fried eggs, black beans, sweet plantains, fresh cheese, cream, corn tortillas, our chapina sauce
US$14.00

Green Tacos

Three tacos with eggs, green sauce, avocado and cheese
US$13.00

Huevos Rancheros

Three eggs, (anyway) spicy sauce on the top, avocado, black beans and corn tortillas.
US$12.00

Breakfast Tacos

Three tacos, with beans, chorizo, eggs and cheese
US$13.00

Heavy Duty Breakfast

Two eggs, tomato sauce, steak, beans, cream, cheese, sweet plantains, Mexican sausage, and corn tortillas
US$17.00

Baleada Sencilla

Flour tortilla, beans, eggs, cream and cheese
US$9.00

American Breakfast

Two fried eggs, home fries, bacon, sliced tomato, sliced avocado and a cuban toast
US$14.00

Corn Beef Hash

Two fried eggs, sliced tomato, sliced avocado and a cuban toast
US$14.00

Desayuno Indio

Scramble eggs with tomato, onions, rice, beans, Mexican sausage, fresh cheese and corn tortillas
US$16.00

Cheese Toast
US$3.50

Avocado Egg & Cheese
US$10.00

Chorizo Egg & Cheese
US$9.50

Bacon Egg & Cheese
US$8.50

Steak Egg & Cheese
US$13.00

Ham Egg & Cheese
US$8.50

Wake Up Burrito

steak, egg, guacamole & cheese
US$14.50

Vegetable Burrito
US$12.00

Egg & Cheese
US$6.50

Cuban Toast (Butter Bread)
US$1.50

Egg Sandwich
US$5.50

Steak Egg & Cheese Burrito
US$13.00

Sausage Egg & Cheese
US$8.50

Breakfast Burrito

chorizo, egg and cheese
US$10.00

Avocado Toast
US$5.00

Breakfast Sandwich